Wishful Thinking. . . US Rhetoric on Egypt

Tahrir Square

Amy Hawthorne, of the Atlantic Council’s Rafik Hariri Center for the Middle East, posted a piece about the Obama Administration’s messaging on the current situation in Egypt.

She states:

“A review of key statements [by the Obama Administration] on Egypt during the past month shows the wishful thinking shaping the discourse as the United States struggles to reconcile its declared support for democracy with the reality unfolding on the ground.”

On March 24, State Department Deputy Spokesperson Marie Harf while discussing the situation in Egypt described politically motivated arrests, detentions, and convictions as “pretty significant bumps in the road here as we’ve tried to work with Egypt to move its democratic transition forward.” In the same statement, she referred twice to a “democratic transition” and to “a country that’s moving toward democracy.”

Sequentially, on March 28, Deputy National Security Adviser Ben Rhodes said in remarks to the New York Times the United States was concerned about the “shockingly large” numbers of people sentenced to death, but continued to believe that stability in Egypt would come through “sticking to a democratic road map.”

Hawthrone’s article continues with multiple examples of mixed messaging by the Obama Administration, expressing disdain for acts of the current authority in Egypt, while simultaneously expressing hope for a democratic government.

These statements lead me to one major observation; that the current relationship between the US and Egypt – which can most eloquently be summed up by the Facebook status: “it’s complicated” – is in fact complicated. The US is conflicted by the need to protect US national interests and the desire to fly the banner of democracy for all to emulate. This confusion is the reason for the convoluted PD strategy and indicative of the weak foreign policy in the MENA region.

Public diplomacy scholars Edward Comor and Hamilton Bean state that, “ethical public diplomacy should be pursued, i.e., a public diplomacy that embraces genuine (rather than contrived) dialogue.” You cannot persuade anti-American Muslims by engaging in rhetoric that is not evident in diplomatic practice. By advocating for democracy and simultaneously supporting autocratic regimes, that violate the principles of which you promote, you lose all credibility.

If the current Administration wants to avoid making the same mistakes of the Bush Administration in the Middle East the United States will need to reorient its policy. Until then, the current rhetoric of the US will fail to resonate with strategic audiences, and the legitimacy of the USG will be as muddled as the situation in Egypt.

Wishful Thinking: The Obama Administration’s Rhetoric on Democracy and Human Rights in Egypt

51 thoughts on “Wishful Thinking. . . US Rhetoric on Egypt”

  1. Points you raised very valid points in your post. It really happened some person do not have the right idea. But with your awesome tips, one can easily identify it.This post is discussing in an outstanding way. I like your way yo discussed your valid points and facts about this. I really said you share more and more articles.

  2. Showbox for PC comes in handy in accessing an excellent amount of free movies and television shows. You can easily watch your favorite shows conveniently by searching inside the application.

  3. VivaTV is a streaming APK which provide you thousand of movies and TV Shows. This APK has a huge database for all movies and TV shows. This APK provides hundreds of movies in different languages including Hindi, English, Tamil, Telegu, and Punjabi from all over the world.

  4. Welcome to French Bulldog breeders home were we have been proudly breeding and showing quality AKC registered French bulldogs puppy since 2004. Our main focus is to produce show quality puppies with amazing personalities suitable for their forever family. We treat every Puppy with individualized care based on their needs to give them the best opportunities in life. Click “Available French Bulldog puppies” to check out our puppies and dogs looking for new homes. https://pitbullpuppy.company.com/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *